Potential for Increased Physician Departure and Worsening Shortage
The proposed alliance between Hawaii Medical Service Association (HMSA) and Hawaii Pacific Health (HPH) is facing scrutiny for its potential to exacerbate Hawaii's existing physician shortage. Critics argue that the alliance's underlying objective is to enable HMSA to more aggressively pursue "value-based" payment models. This approach, which ties provider reimbursement to patient outcomes and efficiency rather than traditional fee-for-service, is cited as a primary driver for primary care physicians leaving practice and contributes to the growing gap in available medical professionals across the islands. While proponents suggest benefits for integrated care, concerns remain about the impact on physician autonomy and practice viability. The full implications of this alliance are still unfolding, but its potential to reshape the healthcare landscape necessitates close attention from affected stakeholders.
More information on value-based care can be found on the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services website.
Who's Affected
-
Healthcare Providers: Private practices, clinics, and individual physicians, especially in primary care, face increased pressure from value-based payment models. This could lead to reduced reimbursements if patient outcomes or efficiency metrics are not met, potentially accelerating retirements or practice closures and worsening the existing physician shortage. Medical device companies and telehealth providers may see shifts in demand based on how integrated care models are structured and reimbursed.
-
Investors: Venture capitalists and portfolio managers focused on the healthcare sector should monitor this alliance closely. A worsening physician shortage and potential shifts in reimbursement structures could impact the profitability and growth prospects of healthcare facilities and related service providers. Real estate investors might see changes in demand for medical office space depending on consolidation trends or the viability of independent practices.
-
Small Business Operators: Increased healthcare costs for employees due to strained insurance markets or higher provider fees could impact operating margins. Businesses relying on a healthy workforce may experience increased absenteeism if access to care diminishes. According to the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, healthcare support occupations are a significant part of the Hawaii economy, and labor availability directly impacts service delivery.
-
Real Estate Owners: A shrinking physician pool could lead to reduced demand for medical office buildings and specialized healthcare facilities. Conversely, if the alliance leads to consolidation and expansion of specific HPH facilities, demand in those areas might increase. Landlords and property managers should be aware of how the health of healthcare tenants impacts lease renewals and property values.
Second-order Effects
- Reduced primary care physician availability → Increased wait times for appointments and slower diagnosis of conditions → Higher rates of emergency room visits for preventable conditions → Increased strain on hospital resources and higher overall healthcare expenditure.
- Potential consolidation of healthcare services under HPH → Reduced competition → Potentially higher costs for services not covered by insurance → Increased burden on self-pay patients and small businesses offering limited health benefits.
- Physician burnout and exodus → Decreased pool of locally trained medical professionals → Increased reliance on expensive out-of-state locum tenens physicians → Higher operational costs for healthcare providers, potentially passed on to insurers and patients.
What to Do
-
Healthcare Providers: Begin reviewing current contracts and reimbursement rates with HMSA. Assess operational workflows and identify opportunities to improve efficiency and patient outcome metrics that align with value-based care principles. Engage with industry associations like the Hawaii Medical Association to stay informed on advocacy efforts and potential regulatory changes.
-
Investors: Monitor financial reports and announcements from HMSA and HPH. Track key performance indicators for healthcare providers in Hawaii, paying close attention to physician retention rates, reimbursement trends, and patient access metrics. Evaluate the risk factors associated with investments in Hawaii's healthcare sector, particularly for organizations heavily reliant on primary care referrals.
-
Small Business Operators: Review employee health insurance plans to understand the network coverage and any potential shifts in costs or access. Consider the impact of potentially rising healthcare premiums on employee benefits budgets and overall operating expenses. Explore options for wellness programs that can help mitigate long-term health costs for employees.
-
Real Estate Owners: Stay informed about any facility expansions or consolidations resulting from the alliance. Assess the long-term demand for medical office space in your specific market, considering the implications of physician shortages and potential shifts in healthcare delivery models.
