Oahu Retail Vacancies Rise: Landlords and Investors Face Strategy Shift as Saks OFF 5TH Closes
Two major retail locations on Oahu, specifically in Honolulu and Waipahu, are scheduled to close permanently as part of a broader bankruptcy filing by a prominent retailer. This event follows closely on the heels of another significant retail chain announcing its withdrawal from the Hawaiian market, collectively pointing to a challenging environment for brick-and-mortar retail.
The Change
The retailer Saks OFF 5TH has filed for bankruptcy protection, leading to the closure of numerous stores nationwide, including its Oahu locations. While a definitive closure date for the Oahu stores has not been specified, the announcement signals an imminent reduction in its physical footprint in the islands. This marks a significant reduction in retail space availability on Oahu and contributes to a growing trend of retail consolidation and store closures.
Who's Affected
-
Real Estate Owners: Property owners and landlords, particularly those with commercial retail spaces in Honolulu and Waipahu, must prepare for increased vacancy. These closures can lead to a 2-4% increase in commercial vacancies in affected retail corridors. Landlords may need to re-evaluate rental rates, offer more flexible lease terms, or explore alternative uses for the vacated spaces, such as conversion to mixed-use or entertainment venues. This also puts pressure on property valuations in the short to medium term.
-
Small Business Operators: While not directly impacted by the store closure itself, these businesses may experience indirect effects. Changes in foot traffic patterns around the former retail sites could influence customer flow. Additionally, a greater supply of retail space might increase competition for desirable locations, potentially stabilizing or slightly reducing rental rates for smaller opportune spaces, though prime locations will remain competitive.
-
Investors: Investors with exposure to Hawaii's commercial real estate market, particularly in retail-focused portfolios, need to reassess their holdings. The closures indicate a potential oversupply of traditional retail space and a need for diversification. This situation may also present opportunities for investors specializing in adaptive reuse or for those who can capitalize on distressed real estate assets.
Second-Order Effects
The closure of major retail outlets has several ripple effects within Hawaii's unique, island economy.
- Increased Commercial Vacancy → Reduced Property Tax Revenue: A significant rise in vacant commercial retail spaces can lead to a decline in property values. This, in turn, can put downward pressure on property tax revenues for the county governments that rely on these streams. Lower tax revenues could potentially impact funding for public services or necessitate a reallocation of resources.
- Retail Job Losses → Labor Market Shifts: The closure of these stores will result in job losses, particularly in retail positions. While some employees may find opportunities in other sectors, a sustained increase in retail vacancies could shift the labor supply, potentially impacting wage negotiations in other service-oriented industries or increasing competition for available jobs.
- Repurposing Challenges → Development Slowdown: While vacant spaces present an opportunity for repurposing, the specific zoning regulations and development approval processes in Hawaii can be lengthy and complex. This could slow down the conversion of retail spaces into residential or other commercial uses, potentially exacerbating existing housing shortages or limiting new business formation.
What to Do
-
Real Estate Owners: Proactively review existing lease agreements for any clauses that might be affected by tenant closures. Begin market research into alternative uses for the vacated retail spaces (e.g., warehousing, entertainment, flex office) and consult with local planning departments regarding zoning flexibility. Consider offering incentives for new, diverse tenants. Monitor tenant occupancy rates and new lease signings in comparable commercial zones over the next six months. If vacancy rates in your specific corridor exceed 15%, explore a formal repurposing plan.
-
Small Business Operators: Assess if your business is located near these now-vacating retail sites. Observe any shifts in foot traffic. Consider if there are opportunities to capture any spillover customers or if increased competition for prime retail space might present a future leasing advantage. Watch local commercial real estate vacancy reports from the Hawaii Business Research Center and local commercial brokerages. If vacancy rates begin to rise significantly (over 10%) in your immediate vicinity, review your marketing strategy to maintain visibility.
-
Investors: Re-evaluate the portion of your portfolio allocated to Hawaii's retail real estate sector. Analyze the risk exposure of publicly traded REITs or private funds with significant retail holdings on Oahu. Identify opportunities for distressed asset acquisition or investments in sectors less impacted by consumer spending trends (e.g., logistics, healthcare, residential). Monitor the performance of retail-focused real estate investment trusts (REITs) and any public announcements regarding distressed retail property sales in Hawaii. If at least three significant retail properties on Oahu are put up for distress sale within the next quarter, consider allocating capital for opportunistic acquisitions.
