Tourism Operators Face Increased Risk of Inflated Ticket Costs and Customer Dissatisfaction Due to Airline Overbooking Practices
Executive Brief: Airlines are increasingly overbooking flights to Hawaii, particularly in premium cabins, leading to denied boarding for paying customers and potentially impacting traveler satisfaction. Tourism operators should monitor these trends as they can affect customer experience and travel plans.
- Tourism Operators: Potential for increased customer complaints, itinerary disruptions, and reputational damage.
- Small Business Operators: Potential for delayed visitor arrivals impacting bookings and sales.
- Action: Monitor airline customer service reports and passenger feedback for early warning signs.
The Change
A viral incident involving a well-known comedian being denied his purchased first-class seat on a Hawaii redeye flight highlights a growing trend of airlines overselling tickets, especially on routes connecting to and within the Hawaiian Islands. While denied boarding is a known airline practice, its apparent increase and impact on premium cabin passengers suggest a potential shift in how airlines manage capacity. This practice allows airlines to maximize revenue by anticipating a certain percentage of no-shows, but it can result in significant disruption for passengers who do show up and have their seats arbitrarily reassigned or denied, often with minimal compensation that does not fully cover the actual cost or inconvenience.
Who's Affected
-
Tourism Operators (Hotels, Tour Companies, Vacation Rentals):
- Customer Dissatisfaction: Tourists denied boarding may arrive late, stressed, or with altered travel plans, leading to negative reviews and reduced satisfaction with their overall Hawaii experience. This can translate into fewer repeat customers and decreased word-of-mouth referrals.
- Reputational Risk: Operators associated with a negative travel experience due to airline issues can suffer indirect reputational damage. Repeated incidents could lead travelers to reconsider booking with airlines serving Hawaii, indirectly impacting visitor numbers.
- Operational Disruptions: Delayed arrivals can disrupt hotel check-ins, pre-booked tours, and restaurant reservations, potentially leading to booking conflicts and staff scheduling issues.
- Increased Ancillary Costs: While not directly the operator's expense, a frustrated traveler might seek compensation or compromise from other parts of their travel chain, potentially impacting relationships.
-
Small Business Operators (Restaurants, Retail, Service Providers):
- Delayed or Cancelled Business: Visitors arriving late or with canceled plans may miss reservations or shopping opportunities, directly impacting revenue for businesses that rely on timely tourist foot traffic.
- Reduced Consumer Spending: Travelers facing unexpected costs or disruptions from denied boarding may have less disposable income for dining, shopping, or local activities.
Second-Order Effects
Increased airline overbooking leading to denied boarding can create a cascade of negative effects within Hawaii's insulated economy:
- Inflated Travel Costs: Airlines anticipating higher no-show rates may adjust their pricing models. Passengers who are eventually accommodated, or who book last-minute to replace a denied traveler, may face significantly higher fares, especially for premium cabins. This increased cost of travel can deter some visitors or reduce their spending on-island.
- Customer Service Strain: Tourism operators will likely face an increase in customer complaints related to travel disruptions. This diverts staff time and resources from core service delivery to managing passenger frustration and re-arranging itineraries.
- Impact on Labor: If visitor numbers are perceived as volatile due to travel unreliability, it could subtly influence staffing levels in the tourism sector, creating uncertainty for hospitality workers.
What to Do
Action Level: WATCH
This situation poses a risk to the seamless customer experience that is crucial for Hawaii's tourism industry. While direct action by operators is limited, mindful monitoring and preparedness can mitigate potential fallout.
-
For Tourism Operators:
- Monitor Passenger Feedback: Pay close attention to online reviews, social media mentions, and direct feedback regarding flight experiences to Hawaii. Tools that track travel sentiment and airline performance can be valuable.
- Review Customer Service Protocols: Ensure your customer service teams are equipped to handle guests who may have experienced travel disruptions. Develop flexible policies for late check-ins or modified activity schedules.
- Communicate Proactively: If a significant number of guests report issues, consider proactive communication to manage expectations and offer assistance where possible.
-
For Small Business Operators:
- Stay Informed on Travel Trends: Keep an eye on general tourism news and airline advisories that might indicate widespread travel disruptions.
- Maintain Flexible Reservation Systems: Ensure your booking system can accommodate potential last-minute changes or late arrivals without significant penalty.
Action Details: Monitor airline customer service reports, travel aggregator forums, and social media channels for recurring complaints about denied boarding on flights to and from Hawaii. If the frequency of such complaints for specific airlines or routes exceeds anecdotal reports (e.g., more than 5% of mentions referencing denied boarding causing significant travel delays), consider updating customer service scripts to acknowledge potential travel disruptions and evaluate the need for more flexible reservation policies for the affected period.



